- Rabbi Steve Gutow
Newsweek released its list of the 50 most influential rabbis in America for 2010 with some interesting characters on the list. A surprising number of gay and lesbian rabbis make the list, and a couple of the rabbis are from Dallas.
Rabbi Steve Gutow is listed at No. 20 for a second year. Gutow, originally a Dallas attorney, worked in Gov. Ann Richards’ administration and went to rabbinical school after she left office. Since then, he has conducted services at Dallas LGBTA Congregation Beth El Binah a number of times and is currently president and CEO of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs.
No. 47 on the list is Rabbi David Stern, the head rabbi at Temple Emanu-el on Northwest Highway in Dallas who has come under criticism by some members of his congregation for one particular position.
Stern will not do interfaith weddings and is clear about that position, but members of his congregation often ask him to perform them anyway. A same-sex wedding he performed at the temple in the early 1990s is often thrown in his face when he refuses to do interfaith opposite-sex marriages.
“But you married those two damn lesbians,” people tell him.
“Yes, and they were both Jewish,” he tells them.
Stern is straight.
Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum takes the No. 25 position. Her New York City congregation, Beit Simchat Torah, is the largest LGBTA synagogue. For High Holidays, they rent out the Jacob Javitz Convention Center in Manhattan to hold services.
Rabbi Elliot Dorff is No. 43. He contributed to the book “Torah Queeries,” which provides an LGBT perspective on the first five books of the Bible and has written on medical ethics for gays and lesbians. He made the list because he chairs the Committee on Jewish Law and Standards for Conservative Judaism, which has become much more liberal under his guidance.
Once again Newsweek ignores the most influential Rabbis with the largest followings: Aron Teitelbaum is grand rabbi of Satmar with a direct following of atleast 100k a network of schools & synagogues across north america & beyond.(MIA) Malkiel Kutler dean of B.M.G. the largest rabbinical seminary in America with branches across the globe.(MIA) Nosson Sherman is the editor & chief of Artscroll the largest Jewish publisher in north america.(MIA) Being homosexual has nothing to do with being Jewish. Most of the rabbis on this list are just enablers, oversee congregations that are predominantly intermarried or just out right media whores. They exert no influence and are simply there to facilitate the gradual withdrawl from Judaism
“A surprising number of gay and lesbian rabbis make the list, and a couple of the rabbis are from Dallas.”
This is surprising to persons who prejudge gay and lesbian rabbis as not influential.
Understand this, to use sexual deviance, which is clearly in no uncertain terms forbidden by the Torah, as a basis for a religious denomination is absurd. A gay rabbi is the same as meat eating vegetarian or a Catholic rabbi, or a Muslim Rabbi, what next a pedophile Rabbi as a leader of the Jewish child molester sect. Just because
somebody wants to call themselves a “RABBI” so he can influence people to hook up for a gay orgy or get a good deal on vaseline is no reason to give them credibility or indulge them.